Good article. I'm trying to decide what to get, and I'm still not sure. I'm a DirecTV user and I'd be the only user, so per your article, I should go with the SOLO. But I'm also an HD user, so I should go with the PRO-HD. Any suggestions?
One factor is that my internet connection has only about 1 Mbps of upload speed. At those speeds, can I even get a decent HD picture? If not, it sounds like the SOLO is my best choice.
Slingbox 101: Choosing Between the Slingbox PRO-HD and Slingbox SOLO - Which One is Right For Me?
In the beginning, picking out a Slingbox was easy. Did you want the Slingbox behind door number 1, door number 1, or door number 1? Since then, Sling (like any other technology manufacturer) has discontinued, expanded, and revised their product assortment.
Today, consumers are faced with the task of choosing between two different Slingbox models, the Slingbox SOLO and Slingbox PRO-HD, with each uniquely tailored to a specific kind of user. With choice comes confusion, so it’s time to get an answer to the question that will be asked by nearly all newcomers to the Sling experience, “Which Slingbox is right for me?"
At a high level, here’s a quick feature comparison of all the different Slingboxes:
| Feature | SOLO | PRO-HD |
| Widescreen 16:9 Support | X | X |
| High Quality Programmable video compression | X | X |
| Watch/control TV from any PC/laptop | X | X |
| Watch/control TV from a mobile phone* | X | X |
| NTSC/ATSC/QAM Digital Tuner | X | |
| Pass-through connections for seemless integration into current setups | X | X |
| Connects to a set-top box (digital cable, DVD, etc.) | X | X |
| Remote control of A/V devices | X | X |
| Connect multiple sources | | X |
| Connect HD component devices | X | X |
| Standard definition streaming | X | X |
| High definition streaming | X | |
| Digital audio input | X | |
| Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price | $179 | $299 |
*With SlingPlayer Mobile, sold separately
Looking at the list above, you'll see that Sling Media has made a major distinction between the Slingbox PRO-HD and Slingbox SOLO. While both Slingboxes have the ability to connect to high-defintion sources, only the PRO-HD has the ability to stream in high definition quality. The PRO-HD is also the only Slingbox in Sling Media's current line up that can connect to mulitple sources. Physical size and styling aside, it really boils down to the type and quantity of devices you want to use with your Slingbox, and the amount of money you’re willing to spend to get into the placeshifting scene.
Basic Cable and Antenna Users
If you’re a basic cable subscriber, or still rely on that broadcast antenna on the roof (you know, the thing you call “ol’ faithful”), your only real option is the Slingox PRO-HD. It is the only model in the lineup with an integrated ATSC/NTSC/QAM tuner.
If you’re receiving basic cable now but are on the fence about upgrading to digital cable with a set-top box or DVR, the PRO-HD can connect to both, providing flexibility for when the set-top box is in use.
Digital Cable and Satellite Users
Satellite users that have an integrated DVR should seriously consider the Slingbox SOLO, since there’s a good chance that’s the only device you’ll ever use to receive and record your programming. Even if you have a separate DVR, you can still access your satellite box with it. So again, you’re down to one source. If high-definition streaming capabilities are desired, then you'll have to opt for the PRO-HD.
Digital cable subscribers that aren't using a dedicated set-top box should seriously consider the PRO-HD because you have the option of splitting your cable feed and running your basic channels into the Slingbox PRO-HDs internal tuner. This would allow you to stream the basics in case a family member is planted on the sofa using the cable box.
If you’re thinking about the jump to HDTV in the near future, it further strengthens the argument to get a PRO-HD.
HDTV Users
If you already have HD services, you should lean toward the PRO-HD. If you’re mostly a mobile viewer or don’t really care about the slightly better picture, and only want to stream one source, the SOLO will do the job just fine.
Multiple Device Users
You have a TiVo, HD cable box, and 400-disc DVD megachanger. You’re the only one that will be using the Slingbox, or you will be the only one that knows the admin password and don’t care if you boot the kids off so you can watch instead. You want a Slingbox PRO-HD. Go get one.
Busy Families

You have his and her cars, watches, and TiVos. Or, you both are absolutely addicted to the Slingbox. Busy,"on-the-go" couples and families may want to consider separate Slingboxes for every source they want to Sling. Though the Slingbox PRO-HD can handle the connection of up to four different devices, but only one person may connect at a time. If you and your other half are both on the road or both want access to something while in or out of the house, the more Slingboxes you have, the better. Grab a Slingbox PRO-HD for the cable box, a SOLO for the DVD changer, and another SOLO for the kids to fight over... because you love to torture them.
Decided? Shop for your Slingbox and Accessories now.
More Related Articles
The Slingbox SOLO Review - It's small, fast, controls just about any external source, and will get you Slinging in no time.
The Slingbox PRO-HD Review - The kitchen sink of Slingboxes. Accepts and streams HD sources, multiple inputs, pass-thru for everything... the PRO-HD has it all.
Slingbox 101: Set-Top Boxes, Tuners, and the Family Battle for Control - There are ways to keep the peace in a Slingbox household. Learn how!
msather said: Good article. I'm trying to decide what to get, and I'm still not sure. I'm a DirecTV user and I'd be the only user, so per your article, I should go with the SOLO. But I'm also an HD user, so I should go with the PRO-HD. Any suggestions? One factor is that my internet connection has only about 1 Mbps of upload speed. At those speeds, can I even get a decent HD picture? If not, it sounds like the SOLO is my best choice.
It's tough maintaining bandwidth for HD streaming remotely, so if you only plan on using the Slingbox from outside of your network, the SOLO would be adequate for your needs. However, if you're going to use the Slingbox in-network, or think you may be able to squeak an HD stream remotely (if not now, someday), then get the PRO-HD.
Matt Whitlock's Mind Over Matt'er - Technology musings, opinion, and more.
Follow SlingCommunity on Twitter | SlingCommunity on Facebook
"SlingBox Pro HD - The kitchen sink of Slingboxes. Accepts and streams HD sources, multiple inputs, pass-thru for everything... the PRO-HD has it all."
Except HDMI.
Note that while the SOLO does not *officially* support multiple sources, you can do it. What you have to do is use splitters to connect multiple audio sources to the same input, then you can switch between the different inputs. As long as only one source devices is powered on at a time it works. If multiple sources are on at the same time you'd hear all the audio overlapping.
That's true of any of the Slingbox models with multiple inputs, like the older AV.
As for streaming HD remotely, the official stance is that you need at least 1.5Mbps. So if your upstream bandwidth is lower than that you probably won't be able to stream HD remotely, and the SOLO would work fine. Personally I have 2Mbps now via cable broadband and I can stream HD, which looks very good on a 15" laptop screen. (I know a 2Mbps H.264 stream wouldn't look as good on a big TV, but imperfections aren't as noticeable on smaller screens.
As for HDMI - blame HDCP.
-MegaZone, GizmoLovers.com
Slingbox PRO-HD w/TiVo Series3, Slingbox SOLO w/TiVo Pioneer DVR-810H, SPM Treo 680, SP WinXP
(Former Sling Media Beta Program Manager.)
I had both the SOLO and PRO-HD but I decided to keep my PRO-HD and give away the SOLO. HD streaming over my network and digital audio tipped the odds in favor of the PRO-HD for me. However both units work well and I was happy with the SOLO during the time I used it.
DDG
Yeah, I have a PRO, PRO-HD, and SOLO. My PRO is currently unused, but I have the PRO-HD in the livingroom fed by cable and a TiVo S3 and the SOLO in the bedroom fed by a TiVo S2. I like the PRO-HD (I may be biased, I ran the beta on that when I was with Sling), but unless you need the true multiple input support or HD streaming the SOLO is solid.
I don't use the digital audio input on the PRO-HD currently, mainly because it is coax. I never understood that choice, every piece of gear I have with digital audio out has optical, most do not have coax - including the TiVo. I bought an external optical-to-coax converter but have never gotten around to hooking it up.
-MegaZone, GizmoLovers.com
Slingbox PRO-HD w/TiVo Series3, Slingbox SOLO w/TiVo Pioneer DVR-810H, SPM Treo 680, SP WinXP
(Former Sling Media Beta Program Manager.)
how many different users can access the sling hd pro at the same time? I am considering purchasing the unit.
Great explanation but I am still totally confused. I have a HD/DVD STB which I want to work independently of my slingbox (used only remotely). I want to get basic cable service out of the house and full HD service in the house. I also want to be able to watch a different station remotely than the person in my home. How do I configure the network/boxes?
Hi,
I am in Dallas and my parents have Comcast, thinking of using them to host. I live in Mexico and to get Dish is a real pain, I have been months without, and I'm about to get Cablevision but its 95% Spanish and old stuff. I'm thinking to try a Slingbox. Can I just use the coax cable, they just have box on main set in den, or do I need to rent an extra cable box just for the Slingbox? Which model should I buy? Also have Iphone 16mb and Itouch 16mb, has anyone tried it? Would be cool to be able to stream tv while lounging at the pool. My wifi reaches.
Hi, Wondering which box to get. I have a HD computer and an HD DVR. Airline pilot so my viewing will be thousands of miles from box. Will I be able to stream HD as long as i have plenty of bandwidth? I'm not desiring to hook up anything other than the HDVR to the slingbox, but would like the HD quality picture. Do I go with the HD or the solo.
Just get the Slingbox Solo, bandwith is an issue until speeds get better, the picture is fine on the Solo, also I have mine on Iphone and I Touch, love it! The Slingbox program has an excellent user interface with the remote on the left picture in middle and program guide on right, when you move mouse you see all and after a few seconds it reverts back to full screen. Debated on Slingcatcher but I got laptop and a Acer Revo mini desktop with HDMI out for my home in Mexico.
Your gonna love it!
Best, KS
Im very happy with my slingbox solo, but, i had lost the guide on the webpage, we installed the program, and the guide worked fine, but i believe the tech reinstalled the preferences not sure, but the picture seems a bit more pixelated than before...here on a 42inch tv, also noticable on computer, video quality is set to high, am I missing something here?
KS
I need help. I read your article but still need help. If I have a satellite receiving system like dish or directv and have hd through their service, which do I want to buy solo or pro hd? I have trouble understanding how hd can get to my computer.
Is there some major feature to the pro hd that warrants spending the extra $100+ dollars?
Please reply when you have time, thanks.
arapahojoe said: I need help. I read your article but still need help. If I have a satellite receiving system like dish or directv and have hd through their service, which do I want to buy solo or pro hd? I have trouble understanding how hd can get to my computer. Is there some major feature to the pro hd that warrants spending the extra $100+ dollars? Please reply when you have time, thanks.
As a satellite user, the major difference between the Slingbox models, for you, is that the PRO HD has the capability to stream video in high definition quality to Windows PCs and Macs in some cases (though HD support for Macs is still in "beta"), as well as the SlingCatcher, on your home network and remotely if bandwidth allows. The SOLO, will stream SD quality only. Meaning, on those devices, your HD quality shows will not be recieved in HD quality.
The PRO HD also has multiple inputs if you want to connect a more than one source.
Matt Whitlock's Mind Over Matt'er - Technology musings, opinion, and more.
Follow SlingCommunity on Twitter | SlingCommunity on Facebook
As you pointed out in another post, one can use up to three video inputs and combine the audio using Y-cables, which are very cheap, so personally I wouldn't spend the extra money unless I needed HD slinging.
We live in England and subscribe to Sky, a major satellite provider in Europe for an HD TV service.
We also have a holiday home in the US and to get fairly basic TV we pay a monthly subscription to Direct TV. However at present we only visit the US house for a about three months a year. Rather than subscribing to Direct TV we would like some advice as to whether we could hook a slingbox up to our UK receiver and


RSS
